Well, it's been an interesting couple of weeks, with a lot more excitement to come.
For now, allow me to post a link to a piece I wrote for the History Press blog, entitled: "Why is Shakespeare's real life (and his death) so undebatable?"
It kind of looks at some of my experiences while researching various aspects of Shakespeare's life (and death) and wonders why so many historians haven't done that research.
Happy reading!
The Future of History
Showing posts with label Anne Whately. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anne Whately. Show all posts
Thursday, 25 February 2016
Friday, 4 December 2015
Shakespeare's Skull - Latest
Working through the proofs of my Davenant book, "Shakespeare's Bastard", due out in February, and coming to the sections which deal with St Leonard's Church, Beoley, the Sheldon Chapel, and the "veritable skull of William Shakespeare" ...
It's been an interesting week, as far as "Shakespeare's Skull" goes. The crypt in which it resides was opened up, this Tuesday, and the skull scanned by archaeologists from the University of Staffordshire. All this was filmed for a Channel 4 documentary, due to be aired in April.
I didn't get to see the crypt, pictured above in a photo from circa 1939, so I didn't get to see the skull either. But here I am, going through the passages on Beoley and the skull in Shakespeare's Bastard, and I turn to an endnote I made about Anthony Wood, an Oxford antiquarian who wrote about Sir William Davenant.
Anthony Wood's close friend and benefactor was "The Great Sheldon", Ralph (1623-84), whose grandfather (also called Ralph) built the Sheldon Chapel alongside the chancel of Beoley church. It was in the elder Ralph Sheldon's funerary urn, deposited in a small ossuary adjoining the vault underneath the Sheldon Chapel, that the Reverend C.J. Langston apparently found the "veritable skull of William Shakespeare" in about 1884.
Wood attended the burial of his patron, "The Great Sheldon", which took place "in a vault situate & being under the Chappell of our Lady joining to St Leonards Church of Beoly". Presumably, then, Anthony Wood saw the crypt, under the Sheldon Chapel, in which Ralph Sheldon was laid to rest. Maybe he also saw Shakespeare's skull in there.
Although the Sheldon Chapel itself was built by the elder Ralph Sheldon in 1580, there is little to indicate when the crypt underneath it was constructed. The assumption tends to be that the chapel came first, and at a later date - before 1684, the year in which "The Great Sheldon" was buried in it - the crypt was constructed underneath the chapel. But is that necessarily the case?
The elder Ralph Sheldon appears to have built the Sheldon Chapel (or Chapel of Our Lady, as Anthony Wood seems to have thought of it) strictly for the use of his own family. It was invisible from the road but accessible from the Sheldons' manor house nearby. The Sheldons were Catholic, and no doubt wanted a chapel to worship in (the black marble altar table in the Sheldon Chapel was reputedly blessed by Pope Gregory XIII). However, the law required everyone to attend a Church of England place of worship. Cunningly, Ralph Sheldon created a chapel which would allow his Catholic family to appear to be attending an Anglican church, as the law required, without actually setting foot in an Anglican church. They attended, rather, their own Catholic chapel, alongside the Anglican chancel. Clever, eh?
But what if a priest had been celebrating Mass in the Sheldon Chapel? What if the family had been in attendance? Where would they hide in the event of a government raid?
The obvious answer would be - under the chapel. Access to the crypt is by removing a couple of steps which lead up to the Sheldon Chapel (the chapel, like the adjacent chancel, being a fair deal higher than the body of the church). Today, concrete steps lead up to the chapel, and these had to be removed to allow Arrow Media to film the skull inside the crypt this week. Previously, the steps would have been stone or, more probably, wood.
Examples exist of priest-holes which were accessed via "false" steps in staircases. A step or two would be removed, or swung on a hinge, to open up the secret entrance to the hiding place. Steps would also have to have been installed to connect the main body of the church to the Sheldon Chapel, and so it would be reasonable to expect that these stairs could have been designed to "open up", allowing access to the secret vault underneath the chapel to those who knew about it.
So, if the G-Men suddenly appeared, surrounding the church and its Catholic chapel, any priest or celebrant in the Catholic chapel could quickly disappear into the vault beneath the chapel, and the pursuivants would find the chapel empty.
The vault is large enough to hold a number of people, possibly for quite some length of time. It would need to have been somewhat more capacious than the average priest-hole if it might have to accommodate several celebrants, plus a priest, all at once. Only later did the readymade crypt become a handy burial vault for the family that built it.
It's been an interesting week, as far as "Shakespeare's Skull" goes. The crypt in which it resides was opened up, this Tuesday, and the skull scanned by archaeologists from the University of Staffordshire. All this was filmed for a Channel 4 documentary, due to be aired in April.
I didn't get to see the crypt, pictured above in a photo from circa 1939, so I didn't get to see the skull either. But here I am, going through the passages on Beoley and the skull in Shakespeare's Bastard, and I turn to an endnote I made about Anthony Wood, an Oxford antiquarian who wrote about Sir William Davenant.
Anthony Wood's close friend and benefactor was "The Great Sheldon", Ralph (1623-84), whose grandfather (also called Ralph) built the Sheldon Chapel alongside the chancel of Beoley church. It was in the elder Ralph Sheldon's funerary urn, deposited in a small ossuary adjoining the vault underneath the Sheldon Chapel, that the Reverend C.J. Langston apparently found the "veritable skull of William Shakespeare" in about 1884.
Wood attended the burial of his patron, "The Great Sheldon", which took place "in a vault situate & being under the Chappell of our Lady joining to St Leonards Church of Beoly". Presumably, then, Anthony Wood saw the crypt, under the Sheldon Chapel, in which Ralph Sheldon was laid to rest. Maybe he also saw Shakespeare's skull in there.
Although the Sheldon Chapel itself was built by the elder Ralph Sheldon in 1580, there is little to indicate when the crypt underneath it was constructed. The assumption tends to be that the chapel came first, and at a later date - before 1684, the year in which "The Great Sheldon" was buried in it - the crypt was constructed underneath the chapel. But is that necessarily the case?
The elder Ralph Sheldon appears to have built the Sheldon Chapel (or Chapel of Our Lady, as Anthony Wood seems to have thought of it) strictly for the use of his own family. It was invisible from the road but accessible from the Sheldons' manor house nearby. The Sheldons were Catholic, and no doubt wanted a chapel to worship in (the black marble altar table in the Sheldon Chapel was reputedly blessed by Pope Gregory XIII). However, the law required everyone to attend a Church of England place of worship. Cunningly, Ralph Sheldon created a chapel which would allow his Catholic family to appear to be attending an Anglican church, as the law required, without actually setting foot in an Anglican church. They attended, rather, their own Catholic chapel, alongside the Anglican chancel. Clever, eh?
But what if a priest had been celebrating Mass in the Sheldon Chapel? What if the family had been in attendance? Where would they hide in the event of a government raid?
The obvious answer would be - under the chapel. Access to the crypt is by removing a couple of steps which lead up to the Sheldon Chapel (the chapel, like the adjacent chancel, being a fair deal higher than the body of the church). Today, concrete steps lead up to the chapel, and these had to be removed to allow Arrow Media to film the skull inside the crypt this week. Previously, the steps would have been stone or, more probably, wood.
Examples exist of priest-holes which were accessed via "false" steps in staircases. A step or two would be removed, or swung on a hinge, to open up the secret entrance to the hiding place. Steps would also have to have been installed to connect the main body of the church to the Sheldon Chapel, and so it would be reasonable to expect that these stairs could have been designed to "open up", allowing access to the secret vault underneath the chapel to those who knew about it.
So, if the G-Men suddenly appeared, surrounding the church and its Catholic chapel, any priest or celebrant in the Catholic chapel could quickly disappear into the vault beneath the chapel, and the pursuivants would find the chapel empty.
The vault is large enough to hold a number of people, possibly for quite some length of time. It would need to have been somewhat more capacious than the average priest-hole if it might have to accommodate several celebrants, plus a priest, all at once. Only later did the readymade crypt become a handy burial vault for the family that built it.
A gap in the wall of the crypt opens into the little ossuary adjoining it - the "bone-house" in which the skull which looks suspiciously like it might be Shakespeare's was "found". This can be thought of as an additional hiding place - a cramped "priest-hole" of last resort, in which a small priest could hide if the entrance to the vault was discovered. It could also have been a repository for all that Catholic paraphernalia (rosaries, vestments, prayer books, candles, etc.) which could not be safely hidden anywhere else. Everything needed for an illicit Catholic Mass in the Sheldon Chapel would be stored directly underneath it, and if it all went wrong, the priest - and some of his flock - could hide in the vault till the priest-hunters had gone.
I suspect, then, that the crypt and the ossuary were constructed at the same time as the chapel above, but not as a burial vault. They were hiding places.
Shakespeare's head, collected after his sudden death - probably by his first love, Anne Whately, whose relatives were supported by the Sheldons of Beoley, and whose family name appears in various parts of the church, including on a churchwardens' chest in the Sheldon Chapel - would have been taken to Beoley church because there was a safe hiding place under the Sheldon Chapel. It would have joined those priestly items necessary to hold a Mass in the chapel above.
There could have been no safer or more sacred a place for such an extraordinary relic as the head of the Catholic martyr, William Shakespeare.
Friday, 8 August 2014
A Warning to the Curious ...
... or "How History Works" (Part II?).
I was flicking through this book the other day. It's on sale at Tudor World in Stratford, where I'm currently doing the odd Shakespeare Tour and Ghost Tour (and great fun they are, too). What's more, the "Horrible Histories" Gruesome Guide to Stratford-upon-Avon is actually dedicated to the owner, and the phantom residents of, the Tudor World property.
I admire Terry Deary's achievement. His entertaining brand of History-Without-The-Dull-Bits appeals to young and old, no doubt to the despair and disapproval of the more academic types out there. And he does a good job of digging up those obscure facts and stories which tend to be omitted from the standard accounts. In that respect, his Gruesome Guide to Stratford is probably a helluva lot more interesting than the typical guidebook.
He even includes the story of Shakespeare's skull! Yes, the local "legend" which I spent months researching for Who Killed William Shakespeare? So, extra marks there for Mr Deary. Except that he concludes his short account of Shakespeare's missing skull with the information that the skull was safely returned to the Stratford grave.
Almost every account I read of the legend of Shakespeare's skull, as originally recounted by "A Warwickshire Man" (Rev. Charles Jones Langston) in his 1884 publication, How Shakespeare's Skull was Stolen and Found, ends with the information that the missing skull was returned to Stratford.
This recurring "fact" intrigued me while I was researching the story. You see, thanks to the infamous "curse" on Shakespeare's gravestone, the town of Stratford, and Holy Trinity Church, have always been rather diffident about opening up his grave. So how, I wondered, had they managed to get the skull back into the grave, sometime in the late 19th century, without anyone noticing, and with no record surviving of the grave having been reopened?
It puzzled me for quite a while. And then, while I was starting work on the manuscript for Who Killed William Shakespeare? - a breakthrough! The skull is still inside the crypt at Beoley Church. It was NEVER returned to Stratford.
Various photos of the skull were taken at different times in the 20th and 21st centuries - on those rare occasions when the crypt was opened up for an architect's inspection - and those photos prove that the skull stayed exactly where Rev. C.J. Langston found it: in the vault beneath the Sheldon Chapel.
Okay, so ... Why do so many accounts of the story end with "The skull was returned to Stratford", when it quite evidently wasn't?
I've never yet managed to track down the source of that little bit of historical misinformation. I don't know who first decided that the skull had probably been returned to its owner, or who first sneaked that falsehood into the legend. But here's the thing: ever since that bit of false information was added to the story, it has been repeated, over and over again, whenever somebody stumbles across the legend, including, of course, Terry Deary, when he included the tale in his "Gruesome Guide" to Stratford.
I'm not attacking Mr Deary. But I am questioning the way that, once a lie has been introduced into the historical account, it tends to stay there, repeated over and over again, until it becomes a "fact".
I've blogged previously about the will which names Anne/Agnes Whateley, the woman William Shakespeare was first given a licence to marry. Because Samuel Schoenbaum failed to find that particular will, he concluded that Anne Whateley was a clerical error: she never existed. And because Sam Schoenbaum said that, it became "The Truth"! Anne Whateley: the woman who never was. But she did exist.
The case of Anne/Agnes Whateley and the case of Shakespeare's skull are somewhat similar. In both instances, something has been introduced to the approved story of Shakespeare which doesn't suit the peddlers of that orthodox account. Whenever that happens, it seems, the race is on to quash that little problem. With any luck, something will quickly get sneaked into the historical record which neutralises the threat posed by that rogue story. So, Anne Whateley, we are led to believe, "did not exist". The skull "was returned to Stratford". Neither statement is true, and yet both have been repeated ad infinitum.
The skull story is particularly intriguing, in this regard. Given that Stratford has, on the whole, sought (a) to ignore the story of Shakespeare's skull - and the actual existence of that spare skull at Beoley, and (b) to rubbish the story whenever someone mentions it, you do have to wonder. If, as the Shakespeare folks in Stratford insist, the missing skull simply could not have been Shakespeare's, then why is it so important that we all believe it was returned to Shakespeare's grave after Rev. C.J. Langston discovered and identified it? Isn't that a case of having your cake and eating it? If it never was Shakespeare's skull, then there's no need to put out the false rumour that it was returned to Shakespeare's grave.
I think the claim that the skull was returned to Stratford was a deliberate attempt to "close down" the story. An interesting legend, yes, but no need to get excited because the skull came back to Stratford anyway. Certainly, definitely, no need to probe any further. Like the mysterious Anne Whateley, the skull doesn't exist. At least, it doesn't as long as you don't go looking for it.
So, someone set a hare running. To stop anyone from really investigating the strange tale of Shakespeare's missing skull - as told by that pillar of respectability, a Victorian clergyman - somebody made up the part about the skull having been returned to Stratford. Which it never was. But that's what you'll keep reading is what happened.
Unless you read Who Killed William Shakespeare? of course!
Seriously, though. History is not, or should not be, a Wikipedia entry, which anyone can alter as they see fit. The facts matter. Anyone who "plants" a piece of misinformation - such as "the skull was returned to Stratford" - is deliberately misleading people. And the people who seem most easy to mislead are historians, who keep repeating the lie, if only to make sure that you don't go getting any ideas.
I was flicking through this book the other day. It's on sale at Tudor World in Stratford, where I'm currently doing the odd Shakespeare Tour and Ghost Tour (and great fun they are, too). What's more, the "Horrible Histories" Gruesome Guide to Stratford-upon-Avon is actually dedicated to the owner, and the phantom residents of, the Tudor World property.
I admire Terry Deary's achievement. His entertaining brand of History-Without-The-Dull-Bits appeals to young and old, no doubt to the despair and disapproval of the more academic types out there. And he does a good job of digging up those obscure facts and stories which tend to be omitted from the standard accounts. In that respect, his Gruesome Guide to Stratford is probably a helluva lot more interesting than the typical guidebook.
He even includes the story of Shakespeare's skull! Yes, the local "legend" which I spent months researching for Who Killed William Shakespeare? So, extra marks there for Mr Deary. Except that he concludes his short account of Shakespeare's missing skull with the information that the skull was safely returned to the Stratford grave.
Almost every account I read of the legend of Shakespeare's skull, as originally recounted by "A Warwickshire Man" (Rev. Charles Jones Langston) in his 1884 publication, How Shakespeare's Skull was Stolen and Found, ends with the information that the missing skull was returned to Stratford.
This recurring "fact" intrigued me while I was researching the story. You see, thanks to the infamous "curse" on Shakespeare's gravestone, the town of Stratford, and Holy Trinity Church, have always been rather diffident about opening up his grave. So how, I wondered, had they managed to get the skull back into the grave, sometime in the late 19th century, without anyone noticing, and with no record surviving of the grave having been reopened?
It puzzled me for quite a while. And then, while I was starting work on the manuscript for Who Killed William Shakespeare? - a breakthrough! The skull is still inside the crypt at Beoley Church. It was NEVER returned to Stratford.
Various photos of the skull were taken at different times in the 20th and 21st centuries - on those rare occasions when the crypt was opened up for an architect's inspection - and those photos prove that the skull stayed exactly where Rev. C.J. Langston found it: in the vault beneath the Sheldon Chapel.
Okay, so ... Why do so many accounts of the story end with "The skull was returned to Stratford", when it quite evidently wasn't?
I've never yet managed to track down the source of that little bit of historical misinformation. I don't know who first decided that the skull had probably been returned to its owner, or who first sneaked that falsehood into the legend. But here's the thing: ever since that bit of false information was added to the story, it has been repeated, over and over again, whenever somebody stumbles across the legend, including, of course, Terry Deary, when he included the tale in his "Gruesome Guide" to Stratford.
I'm not attacking Mr Deary. But I am questioning the way that, once a lie has been introduced into the historical account, it tends to stay there, repeated over and over again, until it becomes a "fact".
I've blogged previously about the will which names Anne/Agnes Whateley, the woman William Shakespeare was first given a licence to marry. Because Samuel Schoenbaum failed to find that particular will, he concluded that Anne Whateley was a clerical error: she never existed. And because Sam Schoenbaum said that, it became "The Truth"! Anne Whateley: the woman who never was. But she did exist.
The case of Anne/Agnes Whateley and the case of Shakespeare's skull are somewhat similar. In both instances, something has been introduced to the approved story of Shakespeare which doesn't suit the peddlers of that orthodox account. Whenever that happens, it seems, the race is on to quash that little problem. With any luck, something will quickly get sneaked into the historical record which neutralises the threat posed by that rogue story. So, Anne Whateley, we are led to believe, "did not exist". The skull "was returned to Stratford". Neither statement is true, and yet both have been repeated ad infinitum.
The skull story is particularly intriguing, in this regard. Given that Stratford has, on the whole, sought (a) to ignore the story of Shakespeare's skull - and the actual existence of that spare skull at Beoley, and (b) to rubbish the story whenever someone mentions it, you do have to wonder. If, as the Shakespeare folks in Stratford insist, the missing skull simply could not have been Shakespeare's, then why is it so important that we all believe it was returned to Shakespeare's grave after Rev. C.J. Langston discovered and identified it? Isn't that a case of having your cake and eating it? If it never was Shakespeare's skull, then there's no need to put out the false rumour that it was returned to Shakespeare's grave.
I think the claim that the skull was returned to Stratford was a deliberate attempt to "close down" the story. An interesting legend, yes, but no need to get excited because the skull came back to Stratford anyway. Certainly, definitely, no need to probe any further. Like the mysterious Anne Whateley, the skull doesn't exist. At least, it doesn't as long as you don't go looking for it.
So, someone set a hare running. To stop anyone from really investigating the strange tale of Shakespeare's missing skull - as told by that pillar of respectability, a Victorian clergyman - somebody made up the part about the skull having been returned to Stratford. Which it never was. But that's what you'll keep reading is what happened.
Unless you read Who Killed William Shakespeare? of course!
Seriously, though. History is not, or should not be, a Wikipedia entry, which anyone can alter as they see fit. The facts matter. Anyone who "plants" a piece of misinformation - such as "the skull was returned to Stratford" - is deliberately misleading people. And the people who seem most easy to mislead are historians, who keep repeating the lie, if only to make sure that you don't go getting any ideas.
Tuesday, 10 June 2014
Crowd-funding - Can you help?
Rebecca Rideal runs the excellent History Vault website.
On that site, she has published a five minute interview with yours truly, and my two posts about Shakespeare in love - The White Lady (about Anne, or Agnes, Whateley) and The Dark Lady, about Jane Davenant. It really is an excellent historical website.
She also organises a monthly Historic Punch event in London's Soho. So she takes her history very seriously.
Rebecca is looking for funding to cover the costs of her History PhD. Now, I've something of an interest in this, because her thesis covers aspects of life in Restoration London, where I'm spending a lot of my time at the moment, working on my book about Sir William Davenant.
To raise the necessary finance, Rebecca has turned to crowd-funding, there being no viable alternative. So I'm putting this post up in the hope that some benefactors out there will take the bait.
It's a good cause - and Rebecca explains it all here.
If you can help at all, it will be very much appreciated. Please click here for more information.
Thanks.
On that site, she has published a five minute interview with yours truly, and my two posts about Shakespeare in love - The White Lady (about Anne, or Agnes, Whateley) and The Dark Lady, about Jane Davenant. It really is an excellent historical website.
She also organises a monthly Historic Punch event in London's Soho. So she takes her history very seriously.
Rebecca is looking for funding to cover the costs of her History PhD. Now, I've something of an interest in this, because her thesis covers aspects of life in Restoration London, where I'm spending a lot of my time at the moment, working on my book about Sir William Davenant.
To raise the necessary finance, Rebecca has turned to crowd-funding, there being no viable alternative. So I'm putting this post up in the hope that some benefactors out there will take the bait.
It's a good cause - and Rebecca explains it all here.
If you can help at all, it will be very much appreciated. Please click here for more information.
Thanks.
Tuesday, 25 March 2014
Shakespeare's Crab
Bought from my local Tesco supermarket: an Old Ordnance Survey Map of the Vale of Evesham & Stratford, dating from 1892.
What caught my eye about this little map was the presence of a landmark - the so-called Shakespeare's Crab. It is marked on the map about a mile outside the village of Bidford, on the road towards Stratford, very close indeed to Hillborough.
The story goes that the young Shakespeare and his mates were disposed to walk to Bidford one day and challenge a group known as the "Topers" to a drinking competition. When they arrived, however, they discovered that the "Topers" had gone to Evesham Fair. But they were invited to drink with another group, this one known as the "Sippers". Even this proved too much for the Stratford lads, who drank so heavily that, on the way home, they all fell asleep under a crab apple tree on the wayside. The next morning, Shakespeare's friends were eager to pit themselves against the "Sippers" again. They roused young Shakespeare who, rather than heading back into Bidford to resume the drinking match, composed an impromptu epigram on the surrounding villages:
Piping Pebworth, dancing Marston,
Haunted Hillboro', hungry Grafton,
Dodging Exhall, papist Wixford,
Beggarly Broom, and drunken Bidford.
Frankly, I've never believed that this little rhyme was made up by Shakespeare. And when we find that the earliest known use of the word "Toper", meaning a heavy drinker, came from 1661, we have to query the factuality of the legend of Shakespeare and the Crab-tree.
What fascinates me about the legend is that, as with so many local traditions regarding the Bard, it might be a polished and prettified account of something more intriguing.
For a start, Shakespeare's Crab is just a field or two away from Hillborough Manor. In previous posts, and of course in Who Killed William Shakespeare?, I have suggested that Will Shakespeare's first Anne - Anne (or Agnes) Whateley - was a resident of Hillborough Manor. This is indeed what local lore remembers: Shakespeare's "White Lady", his jilted lover, eked out her existence as a sorrowful recluse in the secluded manor house which belonged to a man with whom Shakespeare would later do business.
What is more, I have argued that Shakespeare fell in love with Anne ("Agnes") Whateley when he was recovering from an accident, as he seems to have indicated in his poem, A Lover's Complaint. Anne, I believe, was a sort of unofficial or "underground" nun, serving the local Catholics in much the same way that her brothers, John and Robert, served as secret priests in their hometown of Henley in Arden. Essentially, Anne Whateley nursed the young Shakespeare back to health.
It is worth noting that the marriage licence issued by the Bishop's court at Worcester to allow William Shakespeare to marry Anne Whateley referred to Anne as being "de Temple Grafton". Hillborough Manor is indeed in the parish of Temple Grafton, the manor of which belonged to the Sheldon brothers of Beoley (there is a very important Shakespearean connection there, involving a skull, and the surname Whateley is much associated with Beoley and its church). The vicar of Temple Grafton at the time was John Frith, "an old priest and Unsound in religion". Frith's main interest in life, it would seem, lay in curing injured or diseased hawks.
My theory goes, then, that sometime in 1582, when Will was eighteen, he suffered an accident and was taken to the Catholic safe house of Hillborough Manor, a short distance downriver from Stratford, to recuperate. His nurse on this occasion was the "sacred nun", Anne Whateley of Temple Grafton, who fell for the winning ways of the young poet. They arranged to marry, but Shakespeare found himself dragooned into marrying another local woman, Anne Hathaway of Shottery.
The "accident", I always suspected, was the result of violence. For the first part of 1582, young Shakespeare was on the run, hiding out (probably at Earl's Common in Worcestershire) and avoiding the government crackdown on Catholics who were suspected of having trafficked with the Jesuit priests, Father Campion and Father Persons. By the late summer, though, he was back in the Stratford area, where he got Anne Hathaway (and possibly Anne Whateley) pregnant.
If Anne Whateley was a Catholic, as were most of her family, then Anne Hathaway was almost certainly Protestant, her father and brother expressing rather puritanical inclinations in their wills. In the light of this, it might be worth reconsidering those twin gangs, the "Topers" and the "Sippers", especially as the word "Toper" does not seem to have been in use at the time.
A toper is a heavy drinker. A sipper is someone who drinks one sip at a time (and yet, somehow or other, Shakespeare and his friends lost their drinking match against the "Sippers"). Could it be that these innocent-sounding names - "Topers" and "Sippers" - have been substituted for something else?
Let us suppose that the legend really recalls a kind of gang warfare - something along the lines of the deadly rivalry between the Capulets, and their retainers, and the Montagus, along with their retainers, which is dramatised in the opening of Romeo and Juliet. Those two families are, respectively, Protestant (the Protestants wore little black caps in church) and Catholic (the Montagu family, from which Shakespeare's patron, the Earl of Southampton, was descended, were notable Catholics). The gang warfare between those two tribes reflects the situation in and around Stratford during much of Shakespeare's lifetime. It should be remembered that Richard Quiney, Shakespeare's "loving good friend and countryman", the mayor of Stratford and father to Shakespeare's future son-in-law, was murdered in Stratford by thuggish members of the puritanical Greville family in 1602.
In addition to the Greville gang, there were Sir Thomas Lucy of Charlecote and his men. The Lucys and the Grevilles deliberately made life very difficult indeed for anyone tarred with the "papist" brush, and it is not too difficult to imagine Shakespeare and his little gang having various run-ins with either mob - the Grevilles or the Lucys. Any such sectarian violence would not have reflected too well on the Bard, and so his battles with the Lucys and the Grevilles were remembered, a little more bucolically, as hard drinking competitions with groups known as "Topers" and "Sippers".
That may or may not have been so. But I find it intriguing that young Shakespeare was long said to have taken shelter, while very much the worse for wear, under a crab-tree a mere stone's throw from Hillborough, where I have argued that young Shakespeare was patched up after an "accident". He was already torn between two different sorts of gang - the Catholics, which included his own family and the "sacred nun", Anne Whateley, and the Protestants, including the woman he was destined to marry. In that regard, "Sippers" might refer to Catholics, who sipped communion wine, while "Topers" might be a code word for Protestants, who showed contempt for the Catholic mass.
Of course, if Shakespeare had taken a fall, or been knocked on the head, he might have seemed a little drunken when he was found sprawled beneath the crab-tree. I know of at least one scar, running immediately above his left eyebrow, which was there for much of his life, and which caused his left eyebrow to droop somewhat. He also referred to his lameness in his poems, and so we have to entertain the possibility that he was so badly beaten at one stage that he spent the rest of his life with a limp and a pronounced facial disfigurement.
Finally, I find it interesting to note that the word "crab" can mean to criticise or to grumble, or to do something which spoils something else - the term originally having been used of hawks fighting (from the Middle Low German krabben). John Frith, the "old priest" of Temple Grafton, was renowned for setting the broken bones of hawks. And the inn where Shakespeare and his mates are alleged to have suffered at the hands of the "Sippers" was known as the Falcon.
The hawks in question were surely troublemakers. Like today's "hawks", they went looking for a fight. Their enemies were rivals in religion and local politics. And Shakespeare, it would seem, took a pasting. He had to be nursed back to health nearby at Hillborough, where his "White Lady" fell in love with him. But he bore the scars for the rest of his days.
What caught my eye about this little map was the presence of a landmark - the so-called Shakespeare's Crab. It is marked on the map about a mile outside the village of Bidford, on the road towards Stratford, very close indeed to Hillborough.
The story goes that the young Shakespeare and his mates were disposed to walk to Bidford one day and challenge a group known as the "Topers" to a drinking competition. When they arrived, however, they discovered that the "Topers" had gone to Evesham Fair. But they were invited to drink with another group, this one known as the "Sippers". Even this proved too much for the Stratford lads, who drank so heavily that, on the way home, they all fell asleep under a crab apple tree on the wayside. The next morning, Shakespeare's friends were eager to pit themselves against the "Sippers" again. They roused young Shakespeare who, rather than heading back into Bidford to resume the drinking match, composed an impromptu epigram on the surrounding villages:
Piping Pebworth, dancing Marston,
Haunted Hillboro', hungry Grafton,
Dodging Exhall, papist Wixford,
Beggarly Broom, and drunken Bidford.
Frankly, I've never believed that this little rhyme was made up by Shakespeare. And when we find that the earliest known use of the word "Toper", meaning a heavy drinker, came from 1661, we have to query the factuality of the legend of Shakespeare and the Crab-tree.
What fascinates me about the legend is that, as with so many local traditions regarding the Bard, it might be a polished and prettified account of something more intriguing.
For a start, Shakespeare's Crab is just a field or two away from Hillborough Manor. In previous posts, and of course in Who Killed William Shakespeare?, I have suggested that Will Shakespeare's first Anne - Anne (or Agnes) Whateley - was a resident of Hillborough Manor. This is indeed what local lore remembers: Shakespeare's "White Lady", his jilted lover, eked out her existence as a sorrowful recluse in the secluded manor house which belonged to a man with whom Shakespeare would later do business.
What is more, I have argued that Shakespeare fell in love with Anne ("Agnes") Whateley when he was recovering from an accident, as he seems to have indicated in his poem, A Lover's Complaint. Anne, I believe, was a sort of unofficial or "underground" nun, serving the local Catholics in much the same way that her brothers, John and Robert, served as secret priests in their hometown of Henley in Arden. Essentially, Anne Whateley nursed the young Shakespeare back to health.
It is worth noting that the marriage licence issued by the Bishop's court at Worcester to allow William Shakespeare to marry Anne Whateley referred to Anne as being "de Temple Grafton". Hillborough Manor is indeed in the parish of Temple Grafton, the manor of which belonged to the Sheldon brothers of Beoley (there is a very important Shakespearean connection there, involving a skull, and the surname Whateley is much associated with Beoley and its church). The vicar of Temple Grafton at the time was John Frith, "an old priest and Unsound in religion". Frith's main interest in life, it would seem, lay in curing injured or diseased hawks.
My theory goes, then, that sometime in 1582, when Will was eighteen, he suffered an accident and was taken to the Catholic safe house of Hillborough Manor, a short distance downriver from Stratford, to recuperate. His nurse on this occasion was the "sacred nun", Anne Whateley of Temple Grafton, who fell for the winning ways of the young poet. They arranged to marry, but Shakespeare found himself dragooned into marrying another local woman, Anne Hathaway of Shottery.
The "accident", I always suspected, was the result of violence. For the first part of 1582, young Shakespeare was on the run, hiding out (probably at Earl's Common in Worcestershire) and avoiding the government crackdown on Catholics who were suspected of having trafficked with the Jesuit priests, Father Campion and Father Persons. By the late summer, though, he was back in the Stratford area, where he got Anne Hathaway (and possibly Anne Whateley) pregnant.
If Anne Whateley was a Catholic, as were most of her family, then Anne Hathaway was almost certainly Protestant, her father and brother expressing rather puritanical inclinations in their wills. In the light of this, it might be worth reconsidering those twin gangs, the "Topers" and the "Sippers", especially as the word "Toper" does not seem to have been in use at the time.
A toper is a heavy drinker. A sipper is someone who drinks one sip at a time (and yet, somehow or other, Shakespeare and his friends lost their drinking match against the "Sippers"). Could it be that these innocent-sounding names - "Topers" and "Sippers" - have been substituted for something else?
Let us suppose that the legend really recalls a kind of gang warfare - something along the lines of the deadly rivalry between the Capulets, and their retainers, and the Montagus, along with their retainers, which is dramatised in the opening of Romeo and Juliet. Those two families are, respectively, Protestant (the Protestants wore little black caps in church) and Catholic (the Montagu family, from which Shakespeare's patron, the Earl of Southampton, was descended, were notable Catholics). The gang warfare between those two tribes reflects the situation in and around Stratford during much of Shakespeare's lifetime. It should be remembered that Richard Quiney, Shakespeare's "loving good friend and countryman", the mayor of Stratford and father to Shakespeare's future son-in-law, was murdered in Stratford by thuggish members of the puritanical Greville family in 1602.
In addition to the Greville gang, there were Sir Thomas Lucy of Charlecote and his men. The Lucys and the Grevilles deliberately made life very difficult indeed for anyone tarred with the "papist" brush, and it is not too difficult to imagine Shakespeare and his little gang having various run-ins with either mob - the Grevilles or the Lucys. Any such sectarian violence would not have reflected too well on the Bard, and so his battles with the Lucys and the Grevilles were remembered, a little more bucolically, as hard drinking competitions with groups known as "Topers" and "Sippers".
That may or may not have been so. But I find it intriguing that young Shakespeare was long said to have taken shelter, while very much the worse for wear, under a crab-tree a mere stone's throw from Hillborough, where I have argued that young Shakespeare was patched up after an "accident". He was already torn between two different sorts of gang - the Catholics, which included his own family and the "sacred nun", Anne Whateley, and the Protestants, including the woman he was destined to marry. In that regard, "Sippers" might refer to Catholics, who sipped communion wine, while "Topers" might be a code word for Protestants, who showed contempt for the Catholic mass.
Of course, if Shakespeare had taken a fall, or been knocked on the head, he might have seemed a little drunken when he was found sprawled beneath the crab-tree. I know of at least one scar, running immediately above his left eyebrow, which was there for much of his life, and which caused his left eyebrow to droop somewhat. He also referred to his lameness in his poems, and so we have to entertain the possibility that he was so badly beaten at one stage that he spent the rest of his life with a limp and a pronounced facial disfigurement.
Finally, I find it interesting to note that the word "crab" can mean to criticise or to grumble, or to do something which spoils something else - the term originally having been used of hawks fighting (from the Middle Low German krabben). John Frith, the "old priest" of Temple Grafton, was renowned for setting the broken bones of hawks. And the inn where Shakespeare and his mates are alleged to have suffered at the hands of the "Sippers" was known as the Falcon.
The hawks in question were surely troublemakers. Like today's "hawks", they went looking for a fight. Their enemies were rivals in religion and local politics. And Shakespeare, it would seem, took a pasting. He had to be nursed back to health nearby at Hillborough, where his "White Lady" fell in love with him. But he bore the scars for the rest of his days.
Saturday, 15 March 2014
White Lady, Dark Lady
Sorry. I've been a terrible blogger. But I haven't been idle.
Last month, the excellent History Vault website published my article about Shakespeare's White Lady.
This month, the follow-up piece has just been posted. So, with thanks to The History Vault, I'm proud to bring you ...
The Dark Lady!
And let's not forget my illustrated talk coming up at Goldsmiths, University of London, this week, about The Faces of Shakespeare. Believe me, there's some interesting (and maybe even startling) material in this, so if you happen to be in London on the evening of Thursday, 20 March, why not come along? It's free.
If you can't make it, I'll let you know how it went.
Last month, the excellent History Vault website published my article about Shakespeare's White Lady.
This month, the follow-up piece has just been posted. So, with thanks to The History Vault, I'm proud to bring you ...
The Dark Lady!
And let's not forget my illustrated talk coming up at Goldsmiths, University of London, this week, about The Faces of Shakespeare. Believe me, there's some interesting (and maybe even startling) material in this, so if you happen to be in London on the evening of Thursday, 20 March, why not come along? It's free.
If you can't make it, I'll let you know how it went.
Monday, 17 February 2014
Shakespeare's First Love
Ladies and gentlemen ...
I've had another article published online in the past few days. Following hot on the heels of my piece about a "new" Shakespeare portrait, which appeared on the excellent Historical Honey website (www.historicalhoney.com), the following article was published on the equally wonderful History Vault site. Please click on the link below:
Shakespeare's Lovers Part One: The White Lady
Part Two will be published on 15 March.
And I'll be back soon with a proper blogpost!
I've had another article published online in the past few days. Following hot on the heels of my piece about a "new" Shakespeare portrait, which appeared on the excellent Historical Honey website (www.historicalhoney.com), the following article was published on the equally wonderful History Vault site. Please click on the link below:
Shakespeare's Lovers Part One: The White Lady
Part Two will be published on 15 March.
And I'll be back soon with a proper blogpost!
Wednesday, 14 August 2013
Anne Whateley
We've known for a long, long time that William Shakespeare somehow received permission to marry two women.
On Tuesday, 27 November 1582, the consistory court of the Diocese of Worcester issued a special licence allowing 'Willelmum Shakpere' to wed 'Annam Whateley de Temple Grafton'.
Shakespeare was aged just 18 at the time. He was, therefore, a minor, theoretically dependent on his father's permission to take a wife. The special licence was needed because the Advent season was fast approaching, when the Church forbade weddings.
The very next day - Wednesday, 28 November 1582 - two Stratford farmers, friends of the late Richard Hathaway of Shottery, made the 40-mile round trip to Worcester and laid down a substantial bond of £40 to ensure that Will Shakespeare married 'Anne Hathwey of Stratford ... maiden'. The bond was required to indemnify the Bishop of Worcester against any legal problems arising from this marriage.
Shakespeare, of course, married Anne Hathaway, who was anything but a 'maiden' at that time (she gave birth to their first daughter six months later). So who was 'Annam Whateley de Temple Grafton' - the first woman Shakespeare was given the bishop's permission to marry?
The official line, laid down by Professor Samuel Schoenbaum, is that she didn't exist. There was a William Whateley, vicar of Crowle, at the consistory court that day, and the dozy clerk simply muddled up the names of 'Whateley' and 'Hathaway'. So, nothing to see here, move along please ...
Only it isn't that simple. For a start, the 'it was all a clerical error' argument always makes me suspicious whenever a historian advances it. The sense I get is that, basically, we don't know the answer to this one, so we'll assume somebody got it wrong. (There's a similar claim that the island of Ioua became 'Iona' in the 18th century because someone couldn't tell the difference between the letters 'u' and 'n' - that argument doesn't wash either.)
All the same, Sam Schoenbaum's insistence that 'Anne Whateley' was just a slip of the pen has dominated the matter for years. We must all believe, apparently, that there never was an Anne Whateley.
Quite how the clerk also managed to mistake 'Stratford' for 'Temple Grafton', which is four miles away from Shakespeare's hometown, is never explained.
Well, as I explain in Who Killed William Shakespeare?, Anne Whateley did exist.
Pictured above is the first page of the Ultimo testimentii John Whateley de Hendeley in Ardena. John Whateley was a draper of Henley in Arden, eight miles north of Stratford. His will was probated in 1554 - ten years before Will Shakespeare was born.
Named in Whateley's will are his five sons and four daughters. One was George Whateley, a woollen draper based in Stratford-upon-Avon. George Whateley served on the Stratford Corporation with Will Shakespeare's father; he married his second wife in Stratford in May 1582, just a few months before John Shakespeare emerged for his self-imposed seclusion to vote against Whateley becoming the bailiff or mayor of Stratford.
George Whateley was a Catholic: he funded two of his brothers, John and Robert, to work as underground priests in Henley (the first of these had previously been vicar of Crowle; he resigned his post and left the Church of England, allowing William Whateley - his more conformist nephew - to take over).
John Whateley's will also names 'Agnes my daughter', who was still living with her mother when the will was drafted, and so was probably unmarried - and possibly very young - at the time. There is a clue in the will as to who might have been the godmother of Agnes Whateley: one Agnes Fairefox of Barford, a few miles upriver from Stratford.
The names 'Anne' and 'Agnes' (pronounced 'Ann-es') were used interchangeably. Anne Hathaway was named in her father's will as 'Agnes', and so it is a near certainty that the Agnes named in John Whateley's will would also have been known as Anne Whateley.
What this tells us is that there was an Anne Whateley in the Stratford area. She was the sister of one of the colleagues of Shakespeare's father, who was also a near-neighbour to the Shakespeares.
Stratford tradition has long held that Anne Whateley resided in Hillborough Manor - 'haunted Hillborough' - which fell inside the parish of Temple Grafton. Like so many a jilted bride, she lived on as a ghostly 'White Lady', a designation which might also indicate that she was an Augustinian nun.
Nuns were forbidden in Elizabethan England. But then, so were priests - and two of Agnes's brothers worked secretly as priests in Henley in Arden. It is possible that Anne or Agnes kept up the family tradition and served as a secret nun in the secluded manor of Hillborough. The manor house belonged to the Huband family (Shakespeare would buy land off Ralph Huband in 1605), while the manor itself was in the hands of the ardently Catholic Sheldon family of Beoley.
It is interesting to note that Shakespeare, in his curious poem A Lover's Complaint, indicated that one of his early achievements had been to seduce a 'sacred nun', a 'sister sanctified of holiest note'. It is also noteworthy that John Aubrey wrote, later in the 17th century, that Shakespeare left '2 or 300 pounds per annum to a sister' in his native county. No such amount is mentioned in Shakespeare's will - and nothing like 2-300 pounds was left to his only surviving sibling, Joan Hart - so maybe there was another kind of 'sister' (an Augustinian 'White Lady', perhaps) to whom Shakespeare left a generous bequest.
The Sheldon link between Temple Grafton and Beoley is of major importance - for it was to Beoley that Shakespeare's skull was taken (see Who Killed William Shakespeare? http://www.thehistorypress.co.uk/index.php/who-killed-william-shakespeare.html/), and it is also at Beoley that we come across some very intriguing Whateley connections!
So - Anne Whateley did exist. She was not just a slip of the pen.
Now scholars will have to come up with a new explanation for why the young William Shakespeare was granted permission, on consecutive days, to marry two different women - and why pressure was put on him to marry Anne Hathway, when he was already contracted to marry his 'sacred nun'.
On Tuesday, 27 November 1582, the consistory court of the Diocese of Worcester issued a special licence allowing 'Willelmum Shakpere' to wed 'Annam Whateley de Temple Grafton'.
Shakespeare was aged just 18 at the time. He was, therefore, a minor, theoretically dependent on his father's permission to take a wife. The special licence was needed because the Advent season was fast approaching, when the Church forbade weddings.
The very next day - Wednesday, 28 November 1582 - two Stratford farmers, friends of the late Richard Hathaway of Shottery, made the 40-mile round trip to Worcester and laid down a substantial bond of £40 to ensure that Will Shakespeare married 'Anne Hathwey of Stratford ... maiden'. The bond was required to indemnify the Bishop of Worcester against any legal problems arising from this marriage.
Shakespeare, of course, married Anne Hathaway, who was anything but a 'maiden' at that time (she gave birth to their first daughter six months later). So who was 'Annam Whateley de Temple Grafton' - the first woman Shakespeare was given the bishop's permission to marry?
The official line, laid down by Professor Samuel Schoenbaum, is that she didn't exist. There was a William Whateley, vicar of Crowle, at the consistory court that day, and the dozy clerk simply muddled up the names of 'Whateley' and 'Hathaway'. So, nothing to see here, move along please ...
Only it isn't that simple. For a start, the 'it was all a clerical error' argument always makes me suspicious whenever a historian advances it. The sense I get is that, basically, we don't know the answer to this one, so we'll assume somebody got it wrong. (There's a similar claim that the island of Ioua became 'Iona' in the 18th century because someone couldn't tell the difference between the letters 'u' and 'n' - that argument doesn't wash either.)
All the same, Sam Schoenbaum's insistence that 'Anne Whateley' was just a slip of the pen has dominated the matter for years. We must all believe, apparently, that there never was an Anne Whateley.
Quite how the clerk also managed to mistake 'Stratford' for 'Temple Grafton', which is four miles away from Shakespeare's hometown, is never explained.
Well, as I explain in Who Killed William Shakespeare?, Anne Whateley did exist.
Pictured above is the first page of the Ultimo testimentii John Whateley de Hendeley in Ardena. John Whateley was a draper of Henley in Arden, eight miles north of Stratford. His will was probated in 1554 - ten years before Will Shakespeare was born.
Named in Whateley's will are his five sons and four daughters. One was George Whateley, a woollen draper based in Stratford-upon-Avon. George Whateley served on the Stratford Corporation with Will Shakespeare's father; he married his second wife in Stratford in May 1582, just a few months before John Shakespeare emerged for his self-imposed seclusion to vote against Whateley becoming the bailiff or mayor of Stratford.
George Whateley was a Catholic: he funded two of his brothers, John and Robert, to work as underground priests in Henley (the first of these had previously been vicar of Crowle; he resigned his post and left the Church of England, allowing William Whateley - his more conformist nephew - to take over).
John Whateley's will also names 'Agnes my daughter', who was still living with her mother when the will was drafted, and so was probably unmarried - and possibly very young - at the time. There is a clue in the will as to who might have been the godmother of Agnes Whateley: one Agnes Fairefox of Barford, a few miles upriver from Stratford.
The names 'Anne' and 'Agnes' (pronounced 'Ann-es') were used interchangeably. Anne Hathaway was named in her father's will as 'Agnes', and so it is a near certainty that the Agnes named in John Whateley's will would also have been known as Anne Whateley.
What this tells us is that there was an Anne Whateley in the Stratford area. She was the sister of one of the colleagues of Shakespeare's father, who was also a near-neighbour to the Shakespeares.
Stratford tradition has long held that Anne Whateley resided in Hillborough Manor - 'haunted Hillborough' - which fell inside the parish of Temple Grafton. Like so many a jilted bride, she lived on as a ghostly 'White Lady', a designation which might also indicate that she was an Augustinian nun.
Nuns were forbidden in Elizabethan England. But then, so were priests - and two of Agnes's brothers worked secretly as priests in Henley in Arden. It is possible that Anne or Agnes kept up the family tradition and served as a secret nun in the secluded manor of Hillborough. The manor house belonged to the Huband family (Shakespeare would buy land off Ralph Huband in 1605), while the manor itself was in the hands of the ardently Catholic Sheldon family of Beoley.
It is interesting to note that Shakespeare, in his curious poem A Lover's Complaint, indicated that one of his early achievements had been to seduce a 'sacred nun', a 'sister sanctified of holiest note'. It is also noteworthy that John Aubrey wrote, later in the 17th century, that Shakespeare left '2 or 300 pounds per annum to a sister' in his native county. No such amount is mentioned in Shakespeare's will - and nothing like 2-300 pounds was left to his only surviving sibling, Joan Hart - so maybe there was another kind of 'sister' (an Augustinian 'White Lady', perhaps) to whom Shakespeare left a generous bequest.
The Sheldon link between Temple Grafton and Beoley is of major importance - for it was to Beoley that Shakespeare's skull was taken (see Who Killed William Shakespeare? http://www.thehistorypress.co.uk/index.php/who-killed-william-shakespeare.html/), and it is also at Beoley that we come across some very intriguing Whateley connections!
So - Anne Whateley did exist. She was not just a slip of the pen.
Now scholars will have to come up with a new explanation for why the young William Shakespeare was granted permission, on consecutive days, to marry two different women - and why pressure was put on him to marry Anne Hathway, when he was already contracted to marry his 'sacred nun'.
Thursday, 10 November 2011
The Road Less Travelled
It is a problem which affects both Arthur and William Shakespeare. Let's call it the "Don't Look There!" syndrome.
One way of imagining how this problem works is to compare it with a police investigation. There undoubtedly was a time when certain detectives, faced with the task of solving a crime, would make up their minds who did it and then go flat out to convict on the basis of their assumptions and/or prejudice. This led to countless miscarriages of justice, of course. Basically, if you take that approach then you are obliged to ignore all evidence which disproves your theory and, where necessary, cover it up.
This happens all the time in Arthurian studies. The debate goes round and round in circles until somebody raises a question along the lines of, "You know, after x-number of years looking into Arthur, I've begun to wonder whether he might not have been northern, perhaps even Scottish?" This triggers a mini frenzy of condemnation ("No, of course he couldn't have been northern, let alone Scottish; we've looked into it time and time again and there's simply no evidence whatsoever to suggest that he was!!!") And then the discussion returns to "We don't know who he was, he must have been in the south, or maybe Roman, or maybe he didn't exist, we just don't know!"
As you can imagine, that means that the discussion goes nowhere. The Arthurian thought-police have ruled out any inquiries focussing on the North or Scotland, so we're stuck with a resounding "We don't know!" For the record, evidence that they really have looked into the possibility of Arthur having been northern or Scottish is practically non-existent. Like the detective who made his mind up right at the start of the investigation, they simply have no intention of examining any historical candidates - including the first Arthur on record - because that would spoil the game. Better to cling to the (hugely unlikely) possibility that a Roman-ish Arthur will suddenly turn up in southern Britain than to admit that he might have been - urgh! - a Scot!
Shakespeare has suffered from the same narrow focus. A new Shakespeare biography seems to come out every year - perhaps more often than that even. I say a "new" biography, when what I mean is that somebody has taken the opportunity of slightly rearranging what everybody else has said on the subject. But the Smithsonian magazine blog has come up with an interesting, if rather long, piece about one of the lesser-written-about facts of Shakespeare's life:
http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/history/2011/11/william-shakespeare-gangster/?utm_source=smithsonianhistandarch&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=201111-hist
The fact that Will Shakespeare was the subject of a legal document known as a "surety of the peace" is not exactly news, and it certainly didn't make him a "gangster", as the blogpost likes to suggest. But it is a nugget of Shakespearean history which most biographers avoid, principally because we don't really know what was going on and the idea that somebody took out legal protection against Shakespeare and a few others "for fear of death, and so forth" doesn't really square with our image of cosy Mr Shakespeare, gent.
The blog piece does have a point, though. So many biographies, but so few facts.
Well, as the Arthur book - now beautifully titled THE KING ARTHUR CONSPIRACY - How a Scottish Prince Became a Mythical Hero - winds its way towards the printing presses, I have been gravitating towards my next project, which, as you might have gathered by now, will concern Mr William Shakespeare. And I'm seriously inclined to concentrate on a host of facts and anecdotes which are kept as far away from the standard Shakespeare biography as possible.
After all, I have the experience of my Arthur research to guide me. If I'd listened to the vast majority of Arthur experts, I'd have stayed staring into space hoping that one day somebody would find an Arthur who never existed (Roman background, English mannerisms, busy in the south). But I went where they told me not to go - "No, no, we've looked, there's nothing there!" - and found out so much about the historical Arthur that I had to decide what merited going into a 125,000 word book and what would have to be left out.
In other words, I left the path, went where I was told not to go, and found more, much more, than I was looking for.
The same, I suspect, will happen with Shakespeare. Read the usual biographical stuff and you'll end up absolutely none the wiser. I should know - I've read dozens, and none of them told me anything particularly useful or interesting about our national poet.
But I happen to know that there is an awful lot of stuff which has been swept under the carpet by these people (look back a few posts and you'll find out that the first woman to whom Shakespeare was betrothed - Anne Whately - really did exist; you won't find that in any of the biographies). Some of it is fantastic stuff, like the story of Shakespeare's skull, and the work done by German forensic scientists on his death-mask, and why his mulberry tree was chopped down by a fanatical parson (who then completely destroyed Shakespeare's house), and how the "lost" play of Cardenio probably led to his murder after a "merry meeting" with two of his fellow poets.
Only by following those leads which the Arthur experts insist don't exist was it possible for me to find Arthur (and his comrades). Only by following those leads which the Shakespeare experts ignore will it be possible to get to grips with the man and his works.
And then we can start to make up for yet another historical miscarriage of justice.
One way of imagining how this problem works is to compare it with a police investigation. There undoubtedly was a time when certain detectives, faced with the task of solving a crime, would make up their minds who did it and then go flat out to convict on the basis of their assumptions and/or prejudice. This led to countless miscarriages of justice, of course. Basically, if you take that approach then you are obliged to ignore all evidence which disproves your theory and, where necessary, cover it up.
This happens all the time in Arthurian studies. The debate goes round and round in circles until somebody raises a question along the lines of, "You know, after x-number of years looking into Arthur, I've begun to wonder whether he might not have been northern, perhaps even Scottish?" This triggers a mini frenzy of condemnation ("No, of course he couldn't have been northern, let alone Scottish; we've looked into it time and time again and there's simply no evidence whatsoever to suggest that he was!!!") And then the discussion returns to "We don't know who he was, he must have been in the south, or maybe Roman, or maybe he didn't exist, we just don't know!"
As you can imagine, that means that the discussion goes nowhere. The Arthurian thought-police have ruled out any inquiries focussing on the North or Scotland, so we're stuck with a resounding "We don't know!" For the record, evidence that they really have looked into the possibility of Arthur having been northern or Scottish is practically non-existent. Like the detective who made his mind up right at the start of the investigation, they simply have no intention of examining any historical candidates - including the first Arthur on record - because that would spoil the game. Better to cling to the (hugely unlikely) possibility that a Roman-ish Arthur will suddenly turn up in southern Britain than to admit that he might have been - urgh! - a Scot!
Shakespeare has suffered from the same narrow focus. A new Shakespeare biography seems to come out every year - perhaps more often than that even. I say a "new" biography, when what I mean is that somebody has taken the opportunity of slightly rearranging what everybody else has said on the subject. But the Smithsonian magazine blog has come up with an interesting, if rather long, piece about one of the lesser-written-about facts of Shakespeare's life:
http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/history/2011/11/william-shakespeare-gangster/?utm_source=smithsonianhistandarch&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=201111-hist
The fact that Will Shakespeare was the subject of a legal document known as a "surety of the peace" is not exactly news, and it certainly didn't make him a "gangster", as the blogpost likes to suggest. But it is a nugget of Shakespearean history which most biographers avoid, principally because we don't really know what was going on and the idea that somebody took out legal protection against Shakespeare and a few others "for fear of death, and so forth" doesn't really square with our image of cosy Mr Shakespeare, gent.
The blog piece does have a point, though. So many biographies, but so few facts.
Well, as the Arthur book - now beautifully titled THE KING ARTHUR CONSPIRACY - How a Scottish Prince Became a Mythical Hero - winds its way towards the printing presses, I have been gravitating towards my next project, which, as you might have gathered by now, will concern Mr William Shakespeare. And I'm seriously inclined to concentrate on a host of facts and anecdotes which are kept as far away from the standard Shakespeare biography as possible.
After all, I have the experience of my Arthur research to guide me. If I'd listened to the vast majority of Arthur experts, I'd have stayed staring into space hoping that one day somebody would find an Arthur who never existed (Roman background, English mannerisms, busy in the south). But I went where they told me not to go - "No, no, we've looked, there's nothing there!" - and found out so much about the historical Arthur that I had to decide what merited going into a 125,000 word book and what would have to be left out.
In other words, I left the path, went where I was told not to go, and found more, much more, than I was looking for.
The same, I suspect, will happen with Shakespeare. Read the usual biographical stuff and you'll end up absolutely none the wiser. I should know - I've read dozens, and none of them told me anything particularly useful or interesting about our national poet.
But I happen to know that there is an awful lot of stuff which has been swept under the carpet by these people (look back a few posts and you'll find out that the first woman to whom Shakespeare was betrothed - Anne Whately - really did exist; you won't find that in any of the biographies). Some of it is fantastic stuff, like the story of Shakespeare's skull, and the work done by German forensic scientists on his death-mask, and why his mulberry tree was chopped down by a fanatical parson (who then completely destroyed Shakespeare's house), and how the "lost" play of Cardenio probably led to his murder after a "merry meeting" with two of his fellow poets.
Only by following those leads which the Arthur experts insist don't exist was it possible for me to find Arthur (and his comrades). Only by following those leads which the Shakespeare experts ignore will it be possible to get to grips with the man and his works.
And then we can start to make up for yet another historical miscarriage of justice.
Wednesday, 21 September 2011
Chapter and Verse
A few years ago, while I was researching another of my projects, my wife (Kim) and I went to a County Records Office somewhere in England.
There was a document I wanted to find. Basically, it proved the existence of a certain Anne Whately.
We've known for a long time that the first marriage licence issued to William Shakespeare allowed him to marry one Anne Whately of Temple Grafton. The next day, two Stratford farmers coughed up a fair amount of money to make sure that young will married one Anne Hathaway of Stratford (optimistically described as a 'maiden').
The document was there, and yes, it proved that Anne Whately did exist, and that the Shakespeare family would have known of her. Job done.
At the counter, Kim couldn't resist asking if anyone else had wanted to see this document. Scholars, perhaps, or students? The staff looked blank. So Kim told them that they'd got a very important document there - it proved the existence of the woman William Shakespeare had wanted to marry, as opposed to the woman he ended up marrying.
Quick as a flash, a guy with a beard came hurtling over and said something along the lines of:
"Well, of course, the official line on Anne Whately was delivered by Professor Samuel Schoenbaum, who said that she was a clerical error. The clerk at the Worcester Consistory Court got her name wrong."
Under other circumstances, I might have been inclined to argue. However, what I really wanted was to get out of there fast and keep the secret to ourselves, at least until I get round to writing that book.
But, at the same time, I was flabbergasted. We - that is, my wife - had just announced that we had found documentary proof that Anne Whately existed. And straightaway a guy had told us that she didn't exist. Had he asked to check the document? No. He just told us what Professor Samuel Schoenbaum (who also hadn't seen the document) once said about her.
I mention this because I'm anticipating a great deal of this sort of thing when my ARTHUR book comes out very shortly. I think of it as the 'Chapter-and-Verse' tendency.
You announce a discovery. You have documentary proof. But they don't want to see it. Because somebody once said ...
It's like dealing with theology students. You tell them that the Earth revolves around the Sun, and they'll quote you no end of learned sources who insist that it doesn't. They won't look at the evidence. They just go looking for something that somebody else once said. "Well, of course, Samuel Schoenbaum said she didn't exist - ergo, she can't have existed." But here's the evidence that she did. "Well, Professor Schoenbaum said ... "
There's going to be a lot of that sort of thing. Someone once pretended to look into something with a view to disproving it - the equivalent of a policeman standing by a road accident saying "Move along, please, move along, there's nothing to see here." And their judgement is endlessly quoted at anyone who asks awkward questions in the hope that certain issues (such as Arthur having been Scottish) will go away. It's the default position of the self-appointed experts. Rather than considering new evidence, they all line up to discredit it (without looking at it) because somebody once said something else.
It's like that old joke: History never repeats itself, but historians only repeat each other.
So I've snuck a wee quote from Andre Gide into the start of my ARTHUR book:
"Alas! there exists an order of minds so sceptical that they deny the possibility of any fact as soon as it diverges from the commonplace. It is not for them that I write."
At least take a look at the evidence before quoting whatever Professor Dumbledore said, chapter and verse!
There was a document I wanted to find. Basically, it proved the existence of a certain Anne Whately.
We've known for a long time that the first marriage licence issued to William Shakespeare allowed him to marry one Anne Whately of Temple Grafton. The next day, two Stratford farmers coughed up a fair amount of money to make sure that young will married one Anne Hathaway of Stratford (optimistically described as a 'maiden').
The document was there, and yes, it proved that Anne Whately did exist, and that the Shakespeare family would have known of her. Job done.
At the counter, Kim couldn't resist asking if anyone else had wanted to see this document. Scholars, perhaps, or students? The staff looked blank. So Kim told them that they'd got a very important document there - it proved the existence of the woman William Shakespeare had wanted to marry, as opposed to the woman he ended up marrying.
Quick as a flash, a guy with a beard came hurtling over and said something along the lines of:
"Well, of course, the official line on Anne Whately was delivered by Professor Samuel Schoenbaum, who said that she was a clerical error. The clerk at the Worcester Consistory Court got her name wrong."
Under other circumstances, I might have been inclined to argue. However, what I really wanted was to get out of there fast and keep the secret to ourselves, at least until I get round to writing that book.
But, at the same time, I was flabbergasted. We - that is, my wife - had just announced that we had found documentary proof that Anne Whately existed. And straightaway a guy had told us that she didn't exist. Had he asked to check the document? No. He just told us what Professor Samuel Schoenbaum (who also hadn't seen the document) once said about her.
I mention this because I'm anticipating a great deal of this sort of thing when my ARTHUR book comes out very shortly. I think of it as the 'Chapter-and-Verse' tendency.
You announce a discovery. You have documentary proof. But they don't want to see it. Because somebody once said ...
It's like dealing with theology students. You tell them that the Earth revolves around the Sun, and they'll quote you no end of learned sources who insist that it doesn't. They won't look at the evidence. They just go looking for something that somebody else once said. "Well, of course, Samuel Schoenbaum said she didn't exist - ergo, she can't have existed." But here's the evidence that she did. "Well, Professor Schoenbaum said ... "
There's going to be a lot of that sort of thing. Someone once pretended to look into something with a view to disproving it - the equivalent of a policeman standing by a road accident saying "Move along, please, move along, there's nothing to see here." And their judgement is endlessly quoted at anyone who asks awkward questions in the hope that certain issues (such as Arthur having been Scottish) will go away. It's the default position of the self-appointed experts. Rather than considering new evidence, they all line up to discredit it (without looking at it) because somebody once said something else.
It's like that old joke: History never repeats itself, but historians only repeat each other.
So I've snuck a wee quote from Andre Gide into the start of my ARTHUR book:
"Alas! there exists an order of minds so sceptical that they deny the possibility of any fact as soon as it diverges from the commonplace. It is not for them that I write."
At least take a look at the evidence before quoting whatever Professor Dumbledore said, chapter and verse!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




